I think I more or less figured it out

Priority tier

Kyousogiga
*monogatari
Log Horizon
Non Non Biyori
Yozakura Quartet
Valvrave

Filler tier

Yuushibu
Tokyo Ravens
Kill la Kill
Outbreak Company
Galileo Donna

Teekyuu tier

Teekyuu

May actually check out / continue watching if I am really really bored tier

Arpeggio
Gingitsune
Samurai Flamenco
Strike za Blood
Unbreakable Machine Doll

*lists are more or less sorted from highest to lowest priority.